If you loved Mahiru and Amane’s gentle, healing romance in The Angel Next Door Spoils Me Rotten, you’re probably craving more anime with the same cozy vibes, slow-burn chemistry, and character-driven storytelling. This list covers exactly that — soft romance, emotional warmth, shy characters, domestic moments, and couples who genuinely help each other grow.

Whether you enjoy neighbors-to-lovers, wholesome comfort shows, or perfect-girl x introverted-boy dynamics, these 15 anime will feel right at home.

1. Horimiya

Few romance anime come close to the emotional sincerity of Horimiya. Like Angel Next Door, it features:

• A perfect, admired girl with hidden sides
• A seemingly quiet boy who’s far more interesting than he appears
• A relationship built on honesty, comfort, and mutual acceptance

Why It’s Similar:
Both shows thrive on intimacy, domestic moments, and realistic teen romance without forced drama.

Horimiya on Crunchyroll

2. Tonikawa: Over the Moon for You

If you enjoyed the domestic sweetness between Amane and Mahiru, you’ll adore Tonikawa’s newlywed serenity.

Why It Fits:

• Cozy everyday couple moments
• A wholesome relationship that grows naturally
• The girl is angelically kind, gentle, and supportive

TONIKAWA on Crunchyroll

3. The Dangers in My Heart

A surprisingly wholesome romance that begins with awkward misunderstanding and blooms into sincere affection.

Why It’s Similar:

• ‘Perfect’ popular girl x introverted boy
• Heartwarming emotional development
• Quiet, healing tone by later episodes

Danger in my Heart in HULU

4. A Couple of Cuckoos

Though more comedic, this show shares the Angel Next Door DNA of accidental cohabitation and unexpected emotional closeness.

Why It Fits:

• Neighbor-like proximity
• Cute romantic tension
• A kind, caring heroine

A Couple of Cuckoos in Crunchyroll

5. 3D Kanojo: Real Girl

A shy, withdrawn boy forms a tender relationship with a stunning, mysterious girl who unexpectedly enters his life.

Why It’s Similar:

• Boy who struggles socially
• Angelic girlfriend who patiently understands him
• Emotional growth and healing themes

3D Kanojo: Real Girl in PrimeVideo

6. Your Lie in April (Light Romance Recommendation)

Though more dramatic, its central relationship shares:

• Emotional healing
• A bright, angel-like girl helping a depressed boy
• Beautifully soft storytelling

For fans wanting deeper emotional resonance.

Your Lie in April in crunchyroll

7. My Little Monster

A sweet-yet-chaotic romance with a quiet, studious protagonist and a girl who changes his world.

Why It Fits:

• Opposites attract
• Strong character development
• Cute domestic moments

My Little Monster in crunchyroll

8. The Pet Girl of Sakurasou

This classic features a talented girl who needs support, and a boy who steps into the caretaker role.

Shared Themes:

• Co-habitation
• Boy helping girl with everyday tasks
• Emotional dependency and growth

The Pet Girl of Sakurasou in Crunchyroll

9. Kubo Won’t Let Me Be Invisible

A gentle story of a boy with zero presence and the girl who refuses to ignore him.

Why It’s Similar:

• Soft, healing energy
• Angelic female lead
• Sweet, blush-filled moments

Kubo Won’t Let Me Be Invisible on youtube

10. The Café Terrace and Its Goddesses (Light Fanservice Warning)

This multi-girl romance still captures the cozy vibe of Angel Next Door during its wholesome restaurant family moments.

Why It Fits:

• Domestic living
• Found family warmth
• Healing tone at times

The Café Terrace and Its Goddesses on crunchyroll

11. Otonari no Tenshi-sama (If You Want More Angel Next Door)

Some fans don’t know this—but the OVA and special episodes deliver even more sweetness similar to the TV anime. A must-watch if you loved the main story.

Otonari no Tenshi-sama on crunchyroll

12. The Hentai Prince and the Stony Cat (Clean Version Recommendation)

Behind its odd title lies a cute, emotional romance.

Why It Works:

• Unusual boy-meets-girl encounter
• Emotional honesty
• Soft romantic moments

ON crunchyroll

13. The Girl I Like Forgot Her Glasses

Wholesome, gentle, and refreshingly innocent.

Shared Elements:

• Shy interactions
• Domestic ‘helping each other’ scenes
• Warm-paced romance

Crunchyroll

14. Bloom Into You (Yuri Recommendation)

A soft, quiet story focusing on emotional bonds and slow-burn connection.

Why It’s Similar:

• Thoughtful character introspection
• Gentle pacing
• Sincerity over melodrama

PrimeVideo

15. Relife

One of the most emotionally comforting romance anime ever made.

Similar Aspects:

• Healing character arc
• Soft, steady romance
• Beautiful, grounded connection between leads

Crunchyroll

Final Thoughts

If The Angel Next Door Spoils Me Rotten left you craving gentle romance, soft vibes, emotional healing, and warm domestic moments, this list should completely fill that void. Whether you’re into neighbor romances, slow-burn couples, or quiet character-driven storytelling, each of these 15 anime captures a different aspect of what makes Angel Next Door feel so special.

Add these titles to your watchlist — and prepare for more heart-melting moments.